News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Hounded to death :Law bites back but will ban work? 

Hounded to death :Law bites back but will ban work?

19 Sep, 2011 07:25 PM
Dog attacks are on the rise, but will tough new dog laws put the bite on the wrong animals? Alecia Pinner and Jo Winterbottom report.

The shocking death of four-year-old Ayen Chol, who was recently attacked by a pit bull cross in her St Albans home, has sparked tighter state government legislation surrounding restricted breed dogs and their owners.

Councils will be able to seize and destroy dogs classifi ed as American pit bull terriers if the animals are not registered as a restricted breed by the end of this month.

But animal experts say the change has the potential to affect dogs that look like pit bulls but are a different breed.

Fun4Paws behaviour expert Luke Williams travels across Victoria, including to Frankston and the Mornington Peninsula, to sort out dog owners’ dilemmas.

Mr Williams, who describes himself as a ‘‘dog listener’’, said the tough new laws were a kneejerk reaction that would make it more likely for breeds similar in appearance to the pit bull to be mistakenly seized and destroyed.

To prove that their canine is not a pit bull, owners of ‘‘lookalikes’’ such as American Staffordshire terriers, will now require a certificate from their vet or a pedigree certificate from the Australian National Kennel Council or one of their member groups.

‘‘But DNA testing can’t even tell the difference between a pit bull and a staffy because they are so similar,’’ Mr Williams said.

‘‘What happened last month was unacceptable and should not have happened but I work with many biting dogs, from the smallest shih-tzu to Great Danes.

‘‘The key fact is that it comes back to the human. It is the responsibility of the owner to make sure the dog is contained, safe and has the appropriate socialisation. Any dog has the ability to live happily as a dog.’’

Five breeds are restricted in Victoria — the American pit bull terrier, the Perro de Presa Canario, Dogo Argentino, Japanese Tosa and Fila Brasileiro.

Owners declaring restricted breed dogs will need to ensure that their pets are desexed, contained and wearing a specific collar. Owners could serve up to 10 years in jail if their dog kills a person.

The government has also introduced a hotline for the public to report dangerous dogs. At the time of going to press, 229 people had called to report dangerous dogs.

The Department of Primary Industries is aware of 356 pit bulls, including cross breeds, and one Dogo Argentino, that have been placed on the Victorian declared dog register.

According to the Coroners Prevention Unit, 10 people were killed by dogs in Victoria between 1979 to 2010.

The unit was unable to provide the breeds of the dogs before the Weekly’s deadline, but a DPI spokesman said restricted breeds were not responsible for the majority of dog attacks and he believed the three most recent fatalities were caused by two rottweilers and a dingo cross-breed.

In fact, the restricted breeds hardly feature on the department’s list of 309 dangerous dogs that have attacked people.

The list was topped by 47 Staffordshire bull terriers including cross breeds, 30 rottweilers, including two labrador crosses, 22 German Shepherds, 19 Siberian huskies, 14 boxers and 13 Alaskan malamutes.

The top 15 also included whippets, Labradors, Australian kelpies, border collies and Dalmatians.

One American pit bull terrier had been listed as dangerous due to an attack.

The Victorian Injury Surveillance Unit found injuries caused by dogs steadily rose in the 10 years to June 2010 and accounted for 5180 hospital admissions across Victoria; almost a third of these patients were children aged under 14.

In a similar trend in Frankston and the peninsula, the number of hospitalisations due to dog attacks has steadily grown over the fi ve years to 2010, with a total of 205 hospitalisations.

Most of the injuries were open wounds and 64.

9 per cent of patients were in hospital for less than two days.

Frankston council CEO George Modrich said 22 dogs including guard dogs, attack trained dogs and dogs that had caused serious injury as a result of an attack, lived in the council area.

Only one of these was a pit bull and one additional pit bull had been destroyed since 2005.

‘‘All new applicants for dog registration must sign a declaration stating whether or not their dog is a restricted breed dog” Mr Modrich said.

‘‘We have two animal registration officers that conduct regular door knocks throughout our municipality.

Future inspections will also ensure the any dog located on the premises is not a listed restricted breed.’’

Of the 24,152 dogs registered in Mornington Peninsula Shire, only four are registered as restricted breed dogs, all of them pure-bred American pit bull terriers.

The shire’s acting manager of environmental protection Mark Upton said: ‘‘It is not possible to estimate how many American pit bull terriers there are in the shire that may be unregistered, or registered under the wrong breed category.’’

Shire rangers team leader Paul Bonnici said 12 general duties staff spent about 50 per cent of their time on animal management issues.

It was unclear how much their workload would increase when the new laws were enacted.

‘‘It is hoped the state government will assist the shire to properly resource the additional demand for service that is resulting from these changes,’’ he said.

The Municipal Association of Victoria has taken up the baton on behalf of municipalities throughout Victoria and is lobbying the state government for additional resources.

RSPCA spokesman Tim Pilgrim said it was too early to tell how the new laws would affect the association or whether there would be an increase in the number of dogs being surrendered to shelters such as the one in Pearcedale.

‘‘We are still consulting with other stakeholders, including the Bureau of Animal Welfare and other shelters,’’ Mr Pilgrim said.

Restricted breed dogs surrendered to the shelter cannot be rehoused and must be euthanased.

But the Pearcedale shelter had received very few calls about the new laws and rarely encountered pit bulls.

Mr Pilgrim said the DPI’s new visual standard for identifying restricted breeds, implemented earlier this month, could pose problems.

‘‘The statistics do show that any dog of any size has the ability to attack or bite and it is the responsibility of the owner to ensure their dog is properly socialised and trained.

‘‘The RSPCA has a saying about dog attacks — ‘it is the deed of the dog and not the breed of the dog.’’

This philosophy was shared by Mr Williams, who said a few years ago media attention and public fear centred around German shepherds and rottweilers.

‘‘Breeds are very quickly allocated a social status. Pit bulls were bred to be with humans.

It is not a natural thing for a pit bull to go and bite a human. It’s only that the pit bull style dog draws more media impact than a Lab biting.’’

Mr Williams said there was ‘‘absolutely no need,’’ for restricted or dangerous dogs to be destroyed.

‘‘I think an education program is required. Even the most highly stressed dogs can be rehabilitated. The dog should not be a decision maker. If humans don’t fi ll that role the dog will.’’

Mr Williams said although his clients, including some on the Mornington Peninsula and in Frankston, were afraid to tell him that their dogs were pit bulls, he had 100 per cent success in rehabilitating the animals when the owners were willing to work hard and follow the rules.

Every pit bull owner we have worked with diligently has brought their dog back to a happy, relaxed state.

‘‘It is all about educating humans. Does a dog deserve to die because we haven’t done our job?’’

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
If it looks like a pitbull and has the same jaw structure and physical build, then it's a pitbull or pitbull cross. This ambiguity has been the way stupid dog owners have been able to deceive authorities to own these dangerous dogs by claiming they are another bred or crossed with a known non-aggressive bred.
Posted by Art Vanderlay, 21/09/2011 12:38:28 PM, on Frankston Weekly
'Rhodesian ridgeback bull Arab-cross'

That's the most creative made-up dog breed I've heard of, especially the Bull Arab part !

Posted by New Dog Breed !, 21/09/2011 3:57:51 PM, on Frankston Weekly
Is Bull Arab cross a made up breed ?
Posted by Made up name, 22/09/2011 8:08:29 AM, on Frankston Weekly
There is absolutely NO methodology in existence anywhere in the world by which the breed components of a dog of unknown parentage can be identified with any level of certainty. Any government/council/individual/pound who says they can is kidding themselves and committing fraud.
Posted by chris, 22/09/2011 11:05:57 PM, on Frankston Weekly
People imagine you get your wish & there where no more pitbulls in the world. You would be happy right. Well the idiot owners will just pick the next best breed and same problem all over again. I have spoken to vets & they say you can not tell what is a pitbull and what is not. Inoccent dogs are going to die. And your breed could be next. BSL does not just effect pitbulls, under the list is Rotties, mastiffs, dobermans, staffies, german shepards, plus has anyone looked into the cost to the taxpayers to have the ban. I suggest you do. I will be suprised if this gets posted.
Posted by Lea Ladyraven, 22/09/2011 11:37:01 PM, on Frankston Weekly
This law is stupidy at its best. Truth will out when the next dog that bites, maimes or kills another person is of course not a pitbull.


Posted by christy, 25/09/2011 11:45:04 AM, on Frankston Weekly
So New Dog Breed, you are saying Bull Arab is not a breed, I suggest you do some research before posting idiotic comments.
Posted by kaotikjezta, 1/10/2011 12:42:42 AM, on Frankston Weekly

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Dog ‘listener’ Luke Williams with Dexter, a friendly Rhodesian ridgeback bull Arab-cross, which he says could easily be mistaken for a American pit bull. Picture: Lucy Di Paolo
Dog ‘listener’ Luke Williams with Dexter, a friendly Rhodesian ridgeback bull Arab-cross, which he says could easily be mistaken for a American pit bull. Picture: Lucy Di Paolo

Most popular articles




Frankston Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...